The new eagle is more of a cartoon. The new thistle's color is less natural. The hexagons on the new ball are inconsistant. All in all the new one is a simplification.
I'm assuming that the majority of people on this site would prefer the Blue Toon to win. If they do, has it ever happened before in Scotland that the same two clubs, in this case Peterhead and Gretna, earned promotion two years in a row from the same divisions to the same divisions?