I was at the clach game and thought Meekings put in an excellent performance. First came on as a right back and then moved to centre back.. Fair enough his crossing wasn't great but he was keen to get forward, very solid on the ball and didn't panic when put under pressure.
On the other hand, Gilbert played the first half of the clach game and i thought he was clumsy with the ball and without it.
I would rather a dependable defender than an eccentric defender any day!