ALSY

Why would he want to, though? He's going to the club he supported as a boy, on higher wages and with more likelihood of both European football and a Scotland call up. Obviously there are risks attached - he may not hold down a first team place and Hearts' financial position is apparently still very precarious - but to be honest, I think he would have taken this offer once he heard of Hearts' interest regardless of who our manager was. What's more important is, can we hold on to him for the rest of the season and will the new manager put him back into the team? We missed his composure on the ball in midfield badly on Saturday, and I have no doubt that he would give heart and soul for us between now and the end of the season, as he has for the past four and a half seasons.

I think Butcher might be a decent shout. Has experience up here, did OK with Motherwell, knows the scene in in the SPL and I reckon he would be a good motivator and a better communicator than Brewster. I suspect he'd command the players' respect more too. I'd also be happy enough with Craig Brown - seems to be a bit of an arm-around-the-shoulder type, which the squad probably needs at the moment, and again he has a lot of experience, although he's not managed in the Scottish leagues for a long time. Like a lot of people, I have reservations about Robbo. He did a good job here in the first division, but reappointing managers almost never works and his SPL experience is more limited than, for example, Butcher's. If he were to be appointed, however, and we did go down, I think he might do a decent job for us in the SFL. Certainly if he is appointed, I'll back him all the way. I don't think it's the time to appoint an outsider from, say, the lower leagues in England. Whoever the new manager is going to have to work with the squad he has and try to motivate them against the rest of the SPL. I think a manager with limited knowledge of the SPL is more likely to want to bring his own players in and will also be at a disadvantage when it comes to planning tactics against the other SPL clubs that he's never managed against before.

I'll make sure I'm wearing trainers then. Was wearing docs yesterday - it would have taken me until full time to get the feckin things off and I'd probably have fallen over the rows in front in the process...

I'm not sure any captain could make much difference to the morale and organisation on the pitch at the moment. However, Munro has had his poorest season for us so far, IMO. Maybe playing alongside a more commanding centre back in Mihadjuks will help his form to improve. Of all the potential rivals for the job, however - Munro, Tokely, Duncan - I think Munro is (marginally) the most likely to keep his place in the team. Also, changing captain just now would probably have an even more negative effect on team morale. Probably the most painless way of changing captains would be if a new experienced signing was brought in by a new manager and given the role.

I'll be there because I've got myself into the mindset that I have to attend every away game I can make this season, but I'm going into this game with less hope and expectation than I've ever had before a game. Frankly, I don't think we've a cat in hell's chance of avoiding a defeat. By about quarter past four I expect us to be two or three down and for me to be looking at my watch willing the hands to move faster so I can get back to the pub.

I'm also pretty sure we're going down. Glen Mhor mentioned the fighters in the team, but the last few league games have suggested that morale under Brewster is so bad that most of the fight has gone out of the team. I'm not sure a new manager would keep us up, but Gordy makes a point that illustrates exactly why we can't keep faith with Brewster: if he is still in charge when we are in the first division, then the effect on home crowds will be catastrophic - probably below the numbers we were getting in the third division. As someone who goes to away games rather than home games, I will quite enjoy the change of scene and going to grounds I haven't visited for a few years, but it's also sad accepting that the momentum and growth that we enjoyed during the club's first 12-13 years is finally over.

That was the most depressing defeat yet. I barely recall any shots on goal except for Tokely's outrageous 35-yarder in the first half, and a header coming off the bar in the second. To be fair, the weather probably did make it difficult for the players, but knowing what it was like, WHY did they return to the long-ball p!sh that seems to be Brewster's default tactical setting? As people have pointed out already on this thread, the line-up was also wrong again. Barrowman trotted around 20 yards from goal and didn't seem to have either the strength or the guile to make any impact on Hamilton's central defenders; Vigurs was played wide left, which limited his greatest strength, his passing; Cowie was playing in the middle (I think) but as so often this season, just didn't look up for it. What was most frustrating was that Black was left out of the team but named as a sub, when it was obvious Brewster had no intention of using him. The game was crying out for someone who could put their foot on the ball in midfield, make space and make a pass, and Black should have been on after about half an hour. Any positives? Morais looked quite skilful, had some nice touches and made a few ambitious flicks and passes that nearly came off - also, he worked very hard throughout. Mihadjuks looked solid, but Hamilton didn't really threaten apart from the penalty incident, so it was difficult to judge him. The support was brilliant yesterday - fantastic atmosphere in the pub beforehand and really vocal inside the ground. I felt proud being part of it. Unfortunately it was far harder to feel any pride in the team - by 20 minutes into the game, it was all too clear what was going to happen. I can't see any possibility of us taking any points from the next three games under the current circumstances - the team has less ability than any of its opponents and judging by the last few games, it also has far less fight and self-belief. Although my feeling is that it is already too late to save us, Craig Brewster has to go now - the supporters and players deserve better.

Can't remember feeling this much anticipation before a game for ages. Even when we've won, the atmosphere at most of the away games has been pretty flat this season, but with so many travelling and so much to play for it should be great today. Really hope the team do it for us - if we win, I could see a fair few making the trip to Tynecastle next week, even without the cheaper tickets and free buses. Jumping on the train for Hamilton West and Chambers in 2 hours...

This is true, but what puzzles me is that Rooney is the only striker in the team not to have had a real run, if memory serves me correct. Maybe someone could produce the statistics, but I'd guess that he's started fewer games than either Barrowman or Wood this season, yet is still our highest scorer. Why not give him a run with Morais playing in behind him?

Sorry, can I just check - is our end ticketed? I was intending just paying at the gate.

About 700 according to this: http://www.scottishgrounds.co.uk/hamilton_academical.htm Looks kind of frail, doesn't it? If there are 500 of us there and we all do the bouncey at the same time, it could be match abandoned...

The draw is tomorrow afternoon. For selfish reasons would like an away tie, even though we've just won at home at long last. Queen's Park would have been ideal for me if Peterhead hadn't equalised. East Fife would be very nice though -don't think I've been to Methil before.

FT 3-0. Biggest winners of the day - congratulations to the team. Made snarky comments earlier about Brew playing Morais up front when he was apparently signed as a winger, but it sounds like he knew exactly what he was doing. Also sounds like the new centre half had a solid game. I guess we'll get a truer reflection of whether the team has really improved next week. At least they should go into it with a bit of fight and more confidence. I really hope the reduced prices and free buses encourage a lot of people to travel - seems like it's been ages since I last experienced a decent atmosphere at a game.

Morais again! I really hope they can keep this up next week. Confidence must be improved by this, assuming there's no disaster in the last half hour.

Vigurs. Sounded like a nice goal.

HT 1-0. Please, please, please can we get through the first ten minutes of the second half without conceding a goal?

Always said Brewster was a tactical genius...

According to Robbo, Morais is playing up front. Sounds like more tactical... eccentricity, to put it kindly. We need a creative wide player to supply our strikers, we apparently sign one then leave our top scorer on the bench and play said wide player as a striker. Has he any experience in this position, does anyone know? Dundee ahead against Celtic. Boruc howler again.

Just been mentioned on the radio that Pressley is at the Aberdeen game today, although they have no idea whether it is connected with a potential move.

Risky strategy changing half the defence, but hopefully it'll work. Hastings' poor distribution from the back has been annoying me recently, so it'll be interesting to hear whether Djebi-Zadi changes things. Mihadjuk sounds like a big, strong sort of bloke and that's what we've been missing in the centre - Proctor doesn't have the presence to play there IMO. Agree with the other posters about the continued neglect of Rooney. He'll be looking for a move at the end of the season if he doesn't get more chances in the first team. Robbo covering the game on "open all mics" again - hopefully we'll give him something to get excited about.

Nice wee bonus that. I was looking forward to this one anyway - never been to NDP before and I can get a train virtually door to door. Does this imply we're not seen as a big draw, though? What a cheek... Seriouasly, I'd imagine the Hamilton fans would turn out quite well for this one anyway - they're on a good run and will want to support their team against most likely their biggest rivals for relegation.

Absolutely. As well as the potential financial benefits, getting past this game should also boost morale and confidence - that's a far bigger issue than fitness at the moment, IMO. I don't think we should worry too much about "fighting on two fronts" if we go further in the cup and are involved in a relegation battle. Maybe we'll even find out what our best team is... Hopefully Rooney will get a start on Saturday though.

Considering an offer from Hartlepool, apparently - just up the road from Hull.

I thought McBain was worthy of his MOTM on Sunday and was pleased with Duncan also. I don't agree at all with that. Are you kidding? Duncan was embarassing on Sunday. It amazes me the things that I.C.T fans come out with when it comes to player analysis. I fully apreciate that we are all allowed to voice our opinions but to say you were pleased with Russell Duncan's performance beggers belief! I normally prefer to read other fans posts with great hilarity, but I have really had enough of some of the garbage that is said about individual players/staff & e.x staff at I.C.T. Terribly kind of you to deign to post today. I look forward to more of your posts where you tell us all how stupid we are.

He did do OK on Sunday - was one of our better players IMO - but I think that was partly down to how Rangers played (attacking through the middle and mostly keeping the ball on the deck). Against Aberdeen and Motherwell, with high balls coming across the box, he showed that he doesn't have the presence, nor perhaps the positional sense, to play at centre half regularly. And why should he? He's a decent right back being played out of position.