Can anyone tell me .... Who gives the lads the scores on the game, I know it isnt Brew.

I don't understand the question. And why would you want to know?

I don't understand the question. And why would you want to know?

after the game the players are given a rating or score out of 10 by someone, what I am asking is who gives the scores to the S.T.V. to put on the screen, is it STV themselves or is it one of our management, I am asking because the scoring on tv and the scoring in the papers etc are to say vastly contrary is putting it mildly.

whats wrong, did wee Blackie not get many votes.

I take it you mean Setanta and not STV (grampian)

Either way I don't know. These ratings are based on peoples opinions and will differ. They probably have someone at the game to make the ratings and give them a wee report I guess.

Edited November 23, 200817 yr by themann4thejob

whats wrong, did wee Blackie not get many votes.

I take it you mean Setanta and not STV (grampian)

Either way I don't know. These ratings are based on peoples opinions and will differ. They probably have someone at the game to make the ratings and give them a wee report I guess.

? why wee Blackie, he was taken off, so didnt play 90mins so deserves less points, though taking him off was a bad idea, Killi scored after that, it opened the game up for them, but that is another thread, no its not setanta it is STV, Esson and Vigurs were by far 2 of the best but this didnt meet with what was on TV, does this answer your comments.

Yes thank you, I have a much better understanding of the question now.

whats wrong, did wee Blackie not get many votes.

I take it you mean Setanta and not STV (grampian)

Either way I don't know. These ratings are based on peoples opinions and will differ. They probably have someone at the game to make the ratings and give them a wee report I guess.

? why wee Blackie, he was taken off, so didnt play 90mins so deserves less points, though taking him off was a bad idea, Killi scored after that, it opened the game up for them, but that is another thread, no its not setanta it is STV, Esson and Vigurs were by far 2 of the best but this didnt meet with what was on TV, does this answer your comments.

It wasn't really, he was on a yellow and the way the ref was dishing out cards, you'd think it was christmas already !

The match reporter for whichever media does the ratings, based on his or her own opinion. Not being at the game on saturday I couldn't give an opinion on who was or wasn't best but NoW in England gave top marks to Grant, Dougie and Proc.

Edited November 24, 200817 yr by Alex MacLeod