Who would you have to pair G Munro in Defence when McGuire returns to full fitness. Would it Be McGuire Proctor or Duff?

In my opinion it would have to be Duff as he has been immense in every game so far the only blemish is the mistake against hamilton but even in that game he was still one of our better players. Also its about time we had someone who is willin to make that crunching tackle to leave the opposing forward on the deck while still winning the ball.

For me McGuire would drop out as too often he gives away needless fouls outside our own box and picks up too many yellow cards. But it would be close between him and Duff as he is a great defender that has a fantastic postional sense.

As for Proctor i think he is the weakest candidate of all as although he is quick he lacks the strength for a physical battle and that showed a bit when he was pitched against Colin Nish against hibs.

but enough of my opinions lets hear what everyone else thinks

Duff - 6' 2" and 12 stone 6lb

Proc - 5' 11" and 11 st 5lb

Phil - 5' 11" and 10 st 6lb

Who needs to bulk up captain?

your stats are well off the mark as mcguires not been updated for about 10 years and proctors is a few years old too

I was looking at the team photo and McGuire is a few inches taller than Hastings who is about 6' 0" so that must make McGuire about 6' 1" And according to FIFAs description Proctor is 6' 0" and wieghs 69 kg.

Duff - 6' 2" and 12 stone 6lb

Proc - 5' 11" and 11 st 5lb

Phil - 5' 11" and 10 st 6lb

Who needs to bulk up captain?

your stats are well off the mark as mcguires not been updated for about 10 years and proctors is a few years old too

I would have thought that, considering those three have not been anywhere near ten years with the club, the official site would be pretty close to the mark.

i am same height as phil and i'm 6ft and proc is the same as well. why is everyone so concerned about who weighs the most and who the tallest is, its down to who the best is. proc is not a centre back so he shouldnt be played there, he is only put there because brew has to play the players he signed...so finds any position possible for them...why do you think proc got put straight back in against rangers after only one res game...brew isn't even subtle about this, no other player apart from imire would be put back in that fast and thats purely down to the fact that brew favours his signings over everything else whether its the right or wrong choice.

Edited November 19, 200817 yr by CaleyP