I wonder if Maurice Malpas was the real key here. Had the answer been an outright no, I feel that we would've known far sooner than we did. The footage of Butcher at the airport, seemed to suggest a man still unsure about what his future really would be. There's been rumours in the past that Malpas has stood in the way of Butcher attempting to get other jobs (Aberdeen was one I heard, though I have no idea on its authenticity). I believe that this may well have been the case here. Butcher's made it clear to Barnsley that he'd want to take Malpas with him, they've offered him the job and explain Malpas's terms, so Butcher's gone back to tell him. Malpas looks at is, and for whatever reason doesn't fancy it. I wouldn't at all surprise me if this is actually more Malpas's decision than Butcher's - and I'm glad he's made the right one.
One other thing though has crossed my mind. Would things have been different had Doncaster and not Barnsley come in for him first? To be fair to Barnsley, they don't exactly have a lot going for them. They're stranded at the bottom of the league, have just lost one of their main players and the first candidate for the job turned them down despite being unemployed. While they may be a bigger team, with a bigger support, a bigger budget and in a better league, Butcher would have been a fool to take that job. Despite this, he admits himself that it was a different decision to make and had ICT not been on such a high, his decision may well have been a different one. Doncaster though like ICT, are on a high. Arguably, a promotion with them would look better than saving Barnsley from the drop and should he keep in the Championship the next season, Butcher could look back and say that leaving ICT was the right decision. It could be said as well that achieving success at Doncaster, despite being in the lower league, would be an easier task and done far more prominently than it would be at Barnsley. Who knows, they may still come in for him yet and we go through this whole process again. I just wonder though, had Doncaster come in first, then the outcome may well have been very different.
Just over ten years ago, Steve Paterson turned down a lucrative deal with Dundee United to stay at ICT. He and Duncan Shearer then agreed a new deal that would keep them to club for the next five years and proclaimed that there was still a lot of work to be done. One month later they were gone. Terry Butcher has claimed that he will be here for at least the length of time left on his current contract. I hope he keeps to his word.