Nothing "legally" incorrect in the opening post. No judgement as to innocence or guilt has been made, only an allegation as to a players involvement which is in no doubt. If people want to discuss the legal issues surrounding what can and cannot be said on mesageboards then feel free to start a new topic on the subject in the appropriate area of the forum.
Back on topic and regarding whether it is just Black who is guilty of indiscipline, then definitely not. I am sure every player at some point in time has been guilty of it, the difference is that it seems to be a permanent part of Blacks make-up. And whereas it used to come out in the manner he played the game, and was directed at the opposition, it is now being directed at his own club and colleagues. You just have to look at his body language to see that he thinks he's something special and beyond reproach.
Perhaps CC has fed his ego a little too much in the past with comments about it being part of the player and not wanting to temper it too much as it would effect his game, but that doesn't remove responsibility from Black for his own actions. His actions at Dunfermline showed a total lack of respect for the badge, and for me that includes the club and fans. He can stamp his feet and argue with the Ref all he likes, but the moment he tore his shirt off that was the final straw IMO and not so much as an apology was issued for what he did.
His actions in the Falkirk game were as bad, we had gone 3 goals down before half time and things were looking very bleak. Any player half worth their salt would have been fired up to try and reverse/improve the situation, but Black throws his toys out of the pram and starts kicking and lashing out at everything in sight, and despite a warning continues to do so and gets himself sent off. He let himself, his team, his manager, his club and the fans down in unbelievable fashion. If he didn't want to continue then a word with CC at half-time to get himself subbed would at least have allowed us to continue with a full team and have a chance of salvaging something from the game.
In short, Black took indiscipline to a whole new level as far as ICT are concerned, never before have I seen anything of that nature from an ICT player. CC and the Club need to stamp heavily on him for it to ensure that any other players who may have similar ideas think twice about it. I also think that the fact we had had no apology from Black for either incident highlights that it wasn't simply the red mist that caused it, but something deeper ingrained in his personality.