Could an All star SPFL XI beat the current Celtic team?  This years Celtic team seems very poor compared to teams in the past and yet they have had a great season.  They are unbeaten all year and have had a fair few clean sheets on the way.  But if there was a team that could compete with all the best players for the best of the rest would they match Celtic?  If it was a one off i do think Celtic would struggle.

 

 

Mannus

 

Mackay Warren Reynolds Shinnie

 

Gauld Robson

 

Mackay Steven -    McGinn -   Hayes

 

Rooney

 

Open for discussion.... probably not the best team possible but just what i thought of after a few mins thinking,  Its also a bit harder to gauge as some teams you know little about.

 

 

 

 

 

No place for Billy!?

Why bother with a select team when we have got ICT to rip them apart, no need for deserters or anybody else !!!!      

Brill

Raven Warren Meekings Shinnie

Draper Foran

Doran Vincent Watkins 

Mckay

 

A couple tough decisions on who too leave out but i think this looks like an ok team  

Are we talking a Celtic with their expensive imports of Nir Biton, Almido Balde and Teemu Pukki?  I'd fancy Queen of the South would give them a run for their money!

 

(though I'm surprised you rate Rooney above Mckay)

what about one player from each team in the SPFL, think this would give Celtic a run for their money:

 

MacDonald

 

Mackay Hutchinson Reynolds Taylor-Sinclair

 

Kiss Craig

 

Mackay-Steven McGowan Johnston

 

Mckay 

Djemba-djemba

Djemba-djemba, Djemba-djemba, Djemba-djemba, Djemba-djemba

Djemba-djemba, Djemba-djemba

Djemba-djemba, Djemba-djemba, Djemba-djemba

Djemba-djemba

It was close between djemba-djemba and Alfie moon from queen Vic fc (who's apparently county's next big signing) but i didn't want to get my ear nibble off by cat, so there was only one choice.

Could an All star SPFL XI beat the current Celtic team?  This years Celtic team seems very poor compared to teams in the past and yet they have had a great season.  They are unbeaten all year and have had a fair few clean sheets on the way.  But if there was a team that could compete with all the best players for the best of the rest would they match Celtic?  If it was a one off i do think Celtic would struggle.

 

http://www.afc-chat.co.uk/forums/index.php?showtopic=35872#entry1040449

 

Great minds!

 

Anyone not wanting to visit such a site with the weekend coming up I'll post mine on here.

 

MacDonald

Hammell - Reynolds - Meekings - Robertson (Utd) (I'd forgotten about Shinnie, swap him for Robertson)

Hayes - Flood - Rankin - Gauld

Pawlett

Boyd/Rooney/McKay/May/McGinn/Mackay-Steven