Cammy Mackay is only 27. I'd be happy to see him as the first choice. I remember he had a lengthy run during one of the covid seasons when I could I watch on PPV. I thought he was fine then, and I remember saying that I thought his ball distribution was much superior to Ridgers'.
Back then, it seemed that Ridgers would have at least one major panic per game, when he would be caught out by something unexpected - or at least, that he didn't expect. I don't know if that has continued, or has got worse. I remember looking up his age back then, to see when he might be replaced, and being surprised at how young he was. (He's 33 now.)
Only those of you who've seen him regularly can judge his overall contribution - the good versus the bad.
But if he's off, then League 1 should be the place for Cammy to establish himself.