Hypothetical Question, SPFL XI v Celtic?

Followers

February 8, 201412 yr

Could an All star SPFL XI beat the current Celtic team? This years Celtic team seems very poor compared to teams in the past and yet they have had a great season. They are unbeaten all year and have had a fair few clean sheets on the way. But if there was a team that could compete with all the best players for the best of the rest would they match Celtic? If it was a one off i do think Celtic would struggle.

Mannus

Mackay Warren Reynolds Shinnie

Gauld Robson

Mackay Steven - McGinn - Hayes

Rooney

Open for discussion.... probably not the best team possible but just what i thought of after a few mins thinking, Its also a bit harder to gauge as some teams you know little about.

February 8, 201412 yr

No place for Billy!?

February 8, 201412 yr

Why bother with a select team when we have got ICT to rip them apart, no need for deserters or anybody else !!!! :ictscarf: :wink:

February 8, 201412 yr

Brill

Raven Warren Meekings Shinnie

Draper Foran

Doran Vincent Watkins

Mckay

A couple tough decisions on who too leave out but i think this looks like an ok team

February 8, 201412 yr

Are we talking a Celtic with their expensive imports of Nir Biton, Almido Balde and Teemu Pukki? I'd fancy Queen of the South would give them a run for their money!

(though I'm surprised you rate Rooney above Mckay)

February 8, 201412 yr

what about one player from each team in the SPFL, think this would give Celtic a run for their money:

MacDonald

Mackay Hutchinson Reynolds Taylor-Sinclair

Kiss Craig

Mackay-Steven McGowan Johnston

Mckay

February 12, 201412 yr

Djemba-djemba

Djemba-djemba, Djemba-djemba, Djemba-djemba, Djemba-djemba

Djemba-djemba, Djemba-djemba

Djemba-djemba, Djemba-djemba, Djemba-djemba

Djemba-djemba

It was close between djemba-djemba and Alfie moon from queen Vic fc (who's apparently county's next big signing) but i didn't want to get my ear nibble off by cat, so there was only one choice.

1 month later...

March 13, 201412 yr

Could an All star SPFL XI beat the current Celtic team? This years Celtic team seems very poor compared to teams in the past and yet they have had a great season. They are unbeaten all year and have had a fair few clean sheets on the way. But if there was a team that could compete with all the best players for the best of the rest would they match Celtic? If it was a one off i do think Celtic would struggle.

http://www.afc-chat.co.uk/forums/index.php?showtopic=35872#entry1040449

Great minds!

Anyone not wanting to visit such a site with the weekend coming up I'll post mine on here.

MacDonald

Hammell - Reynolds - Meekings - Robertson (Utd) (I'd forgotten about Shinnie, swap him for Robertson)

Hayes - Flood - Rankin - Gauld

Pawlett

Boyd/Rooney/McKay/May/McGinn/Mackay-Steven

Create an account or sign in to comment

Followers

Go to topic listing

No registered users viewing this page.

KDM Trophy 26/27

Those six games were key in getting oscar , jordan and others up to speed and also supporting a two squad team.

By Moogthurso · 18 hours ago18 hr
KDM Trophy 26/27

So getting promoted means we have six games fewer than last season. Not everyone will agree, but I think that's a good thing.

By snorbens_caleyman · 20 hours ago20 hr
Pre-Season Friendlies

Cove (away) on Tuesday 7 July with a 1900 kick off.

By Robert · 20 hours ago20 hr
KDM Trophy 26/27

KDM Evolution Trophy 2026/27
SPFL announces expanded KDM Evolution Trophy format
The SPFL has today announced the format of the KDM Evolution Trophy for season 2026/27.
Following the success of last season’s revamped competition – which included an inaugural league phase – season 2026/27 will now see more clubs compete in an expanded 40-club league phase.
The following 10 guest clubs across the Scottish Highland Football League and the Scottish Lowland Football League East and West have accepted invitations into this season’s competition:
Banks o’ Dee
Berwick Rangers
Bonnyrigg Rose
Clachnacuddin
Clydebank
Cowdenbeath
Cumbernauld Colts
Formartine United
Fraserburgh
Gala Fairydean Rovers
They will join 10 William Hill League 1, 10 William Hill League 2 and 10 William Hill Premiership B-teams in the tournament’s opening round.
Clubs participating in the league phase will be split into four pots by division, with each club playing two different opponents from each other pot, totalling six matches. William Hill Premiership B-teams will again play all league phase matches away from home.
Points gained by clubs across six matchdays will feed into one league table, with the top 22 clubs qualifying for the knock-out Round of 32.
William Hill Championship clubs will enter the competition in the Round of 32 as seeded clubs, alongside teams finishing in the top six of the league phase, with the remainder of the competition following a traditional knock-out format.
Member clubs and the Scottish FA considered the new set-up hugely beneficial for youth players in providing more opportunities in the key ‘transition phase’ of ages 16-21, as players move from the academy environment to senior football. Youth prospects aged 15 will continue to be eligible to participate in the KDM Evolution Trophy, following a successful trial. The Scottish FA Cooperation System, which was designed to strengthen youth development in Scotland, has also been extended.
Neil Doncaster, group chief executive of the SPFL, said: “We are delighted to build on the success of last season’s new-look competition by inviting 10 guest clubs to participate in next season’s tournament, which will be sure to benefit the community clubs we have invited and provide new challenges for our member clubs.
“While we will continue to minimise travel with broadly regionalised league phase matches, following discussions with our members, home clubs will now retain gate receipts in full in the league phase, to support clubs financially.”
Over £1.3 million in prize money was shared with clubs for last season’s KDM Evolution Trophy, which was an increase of more than 50% on the previous year. The SPFL is pleased to confirm that last season’s prize money has been maintained for the 2026/27 tournament, with the winners receiving £150,000, and the runners-up £100,000.
The Scottish-based, internationally operating construction firm, KDM Group, remain proud title sponsors of the competition.
Iain Jones, Chief Executive of KDM Group, said: “We are extremely excited to continue our partnership with the KDM Evolution Trophy after a highly successful first season of the new-look competition. Next season’s expanded format promises to deliver even more excitement and opportunities to clubs and players across the country, which reflects KDM Group’s support for Scottish football across all levels of the game.”

The KDM Evolution Trophy league phase will commence on the midweek of August 11/12, where participants will look to better Inverness Caledonian Thistle’s run to the final last season. Championship clubs will again enter at the Round of 32 stage on November 3/4, with the 2026/27 showpiece final taking place on either the weekend of March 27/28 or April 3/4.
The fixtures for the 2026/27 KDM Evolution Trophy league phase will be published on Thursday 16 July at 1.00pm.
The full schedule of prize money for the KDM Evolution Trophy is set out below:
Winners: £150,000
Runners-up: £100,000
Eliminated in semi-finals: £75,000
Eliminated in quarter-finals: £50,000
Eliminated in Round of 16: £40,000
Eliminated in Round of 32: £30,000
Eliminated in league phase: £15,000 - £18,500 (depending on final league position)
A summary of key competition dates is set out below:
League Phase MD1: August 11/12
League Phase MD2: August 25/26
League Phase MD3: September 8/9
League Phase MD4: September 22/23
League Phase MD5: September 26/27
League Phase MD6: October 13
Round of 32: November 3/4
Round of 16: November 24/25
Quarter-finals: January 12/13
Semi-finals: February 9/10
Final: March 27/28 or April 3/4

By tm4tj · 23 hours ago23 hr
World Cup

I agree with that.
I can't see Argentina repeating and my Brazilian colleague tells me that they are not good right now, although in Brazilian terms that likely translates to only being good enough for the quarters or semis! No other country springs to mind as an eventual winner other than France or Spain although Spain also have a bit of controversy going on after naming no Real Madrid players to the squad.

Don't know what to make of Haiti. That's a pretty good result but looking at the squad list there are only a handful of players at recognisable clubs. One of them - Derrick Etienne Jr - plays for Toronto so I see him every week. A pacy winger, who will be familiar with the stadium in Boston, but someone who flatters to deceive most weeks. Scored something like 8 in 46 games for Haiti and only 5 in 60 for Toronto but popped up just a couple of weeks ago to score an absolute banger against Charlotte. Hopefully that is him done scoring for the season - internationally at least!
Not that I put much faith in the rankings, but it does have to be noted that Haiti are 83rd and New Zealand are 85th. The two lowest ranked teams in the tournament. Even Cape Verde (69) and Curacao (82) are ahead of them. Scotland are at #43. What surprised me - in the rankings - is that Ghana, who I thought were higher ranked, are listed at 74th spot so round of the 'worst five' according to the rankings.

By Scotty · Yesterday at 02:03 PM1 day

Hypothetical Question, SPFL XI v Celtic?

Featured Replies

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

Posts

KDM Trophy 26/27

KDM Trophy 26/27

Pre-Season Friendlies

KDM Trophy 26/27

World Cup

Topics

KDM Trophy 26/27

Pre-Season Friendlies

World Cup

ICT Squad 2026/27

PSG - The new benchmark.

Blog Entries

Across The Pond - World Cup Approaching: Part 2

Across The Pond - World Cup Approaching: Part 1a

Across The Pond - World Cup Approaching: Part 1

Across The Pond - World Cup Edition

Across The Pond - World Cup Preparation

Important Information

Account

Navigation

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)

Chrome (Desktop)

Safari (iOS 16.4+)

Safari (macOS)

Edge (Android)

Edge (Desktop)

Firefox (Android)

Firefox (Desktop)