No, it's just you (that's become more arrogant, judging by some of your dismissive posts on just about anything) :thumb04:
I'm not, er, assured. Care to provide a bit more than just prejudice? In my experience, the tourists think it's what makes the Isles what they are.
Before anybody accuses me of representing the 'Gaelic Gang' (eh?) can I say Mrs Mantis is a native speaker from Lewis and I visit the Isles every year. I did a learner's O Grade over 20 years ago and find the language and culture fascinating - but not something that should be preserved artificially. That would be pathetic. Maybe to push Gaelic in the Sneckie area is too much (but let's have some reasoned argument without the abuse).
However I do think some effort should be put into preserving it (in the heartlands) and just see whether it bottoms out and recovers, or continues to die. This would be a small price, in return for all the efforts by various governments since Culloden to eradicate the language and the culture completely, ethnic cleansing in effect.
In my experience over 30 years, all of you won't have much to worry about shortly as all the natives are dying off anyway.
Quite right Mantis, the sad but true fact off life in the Western Isles is the rejection, in large part, by the young of Gaelic. I work in that area and hear Gaelic spoken all the time. They certainly have a different culture and a possibly better way of life but I fear that it is doomed. I have to admit that I know very little of the language despite having a family heritage, my mother spoke the Gaelic as a first choice and was forced to speak the english at school, understand only a little myself.
The Gaels now have Gaelic language first schools, even in the sneck but it won't save the language, except as part of some romantic and improbable history. Perhaps we have to let times change and some things are not worth preserving at any cost.