I think they would probably generate some atmosphere but i see it as being a fad and would more than likely be forgotten about within weeks/months.

However it raises health and safety issues, if your not allowed into certain stadia with plastic bottles, cans, flag poles etc surely a vuvuzela would be deemed dangerous by health and saftey officials?

Vuvuzelas do not create atmosphere, they create noise.

Vuvuzelas do not create atmosphere, they create noise.

Well not in the strictest sense but more noise usually leads to a better atmosphere

At this point I'm not bothered, but I may feel differently after I've 'experienced' the vuvuzelas' distinctive din.

They shouldn't be banned, but nor should they be blown within 25 feet of me.

ban them , there humming

Vuvuzelas do not create atmosphere, they create noise.

Well not in the strictest sense but more noise usually leads to a better atmosphere

It doesnt create an atmosphere it creates a constant drone :(

I see Spurs and Arsenal have banned them , hopefully we will follow suit .

If anything, vuvuzelas are no worse than bagpipes. In fact, bagpipes are worse!

If anything, vuvuzelas are no worse than bagpipes. In fact, bagpipes are worse!

When was the last time you watched a game and half the crowd were playing bagpipes for the entire 90 minutes ?

I would be quite keen to see someone invent vuvuzelapipes. That would get the crowd going.

If anything, vuvuzelas are no worse than bagpipes. In fact, bagpipes are worse!

When was the last time you watched a game and half the crowd were playing bagpipes for the entire 90 minutes ?

I don't think I've ever been to a game where anyone had a vuvuzela, and I doubt will be seeing much of them in the future here.

I don't think I've ever been to a game where anyone had a vuvuzela, and I doubt will be seeing much of them in the future here.

A young lad had one at Forres on Saturday. He made occasional attempts at getting a noise out of it. It did not appear to be easy. The sound of one lone vuvuzela was not in the least impressive or off-putting, just kinda sad

Birmingham have now banned them .

I hope they are not allowed in the stadium then we can allpick up a free green and white one at the septic game.

Birmingham have now banned them .

As have Tottenham and Arsenal.

I would be quite keen to see someone invent vuvuzelapipes.

Darn. I thought you were meaning some sort of African smoking device. Gutted!

I would be quite keen to see someone invent vuvuzelapipes.

Darn. I thought you were meaning some sort of African smoking device. Gutted!

Something like this:

if people want to take them let them. Anything that would help drown out the bigots oin the south stand should be welcomed with open arms. And if they are blew in time then it could be interesting