Robert 588 Report post Posted July 5 We could have two threads to cover both! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
alwaysblue 24 Report post Posted July 6 Exactly- difficult comparing part time but charismatic keeper with a full time but steady eddie( boring ) one ! Played at different levels too. Both worthy 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SMEE 331 Report post Posted July 6 Actually...thinking about my selection.....id amend it so that Dods played instead of Munro Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
wynthank15 160 Report post Posted July 9 Brill Tokely... Dodds...Meekings...Shinnie Watkins...Christie...Sheerin...Robson Wyness...Stewart Subs: Calder, Mann, Ryan Christie (if I wasn't playing two wide and two up front and two overlapping full backs he would be in) Wilson, Dargo. Picking the best players in their positions doesn't necessarily produce the best unit. With so many attacking players could possibly do with someone sitting in front of the back four like Warren. PS Don't understand Duncan as meriting a place, great servant and hard worker like Black but couldn't pass accurately beyond his shadow saw too many counter attacks break down with his inability to make a simple pass. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Scotty 2,377 Report post Posted July 9 34 minutes ago, wynthank15 said: Brill Watkins Subs: Ryan Christie, Dargo. Those 4 - while good choices - don’t meet the criteria laid down by club (100 appearances). Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Div1309 8 Report post Posted July 10 brown Tokely Mann Munro Shinnie Wilson Christie Sheerin Robson Wyness Rooney Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
IMMORTAL HOWDEN ENDER 4,785 Report post Posted July 10 Is that not the great thing about football - we all have our favourite players, favourite moments and who cares if anyone actually disagrees. 4 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Scarlet Pimple 968 Report post Posted July 10 SO YOU HAVE PICKED CALDER IN GOAL? HE MUST HAVE BEEN VERY HOT THEN ? ALMOST AS HOT AS IF HE HAD JUST STEPPED OUT OF A CALDERON, EH? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
IMMORTAL HOWDEN ENDER 4,785 Report post Posted July 10 You are forgetting that the climate is Calder over here, the nights get Black and in such conditions we all have to Mann up. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Scarlet Pimple 968 Report post Posted July 10 Now there's a Mann after my own heart. Don't take life TOO seriously afore ye go. It's fallible and soon over. Aye. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Scotty 2,377 Report post Posted July 10 27 minutes ago, IMMORTAL HOWDEN ENDER said: You are forgetting that the climate is Calder over here, the nights get Black and in such conditions we all have to Mann up. You are Bagan for a red dot. You are setting the (Marco De) Barros very (Tony) Low. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
+bughtmaster 951 Report post Posted July 10 57 minutes ago, Scarlet Pimple said: Now there's a Mann after my own heart. Don't take life TOO seriously afore ye go. It's fallible and soon over. Aye. 46 minutes ago, Scotty said: You are Bagan for a red dot. You are setting the (Marco De) Barros very (Tony) Low. 1 hour ago, IMMORTAL HOWDEN ENDER said: You are forgetting that the climate is Calder over here, the nights get Black and in such conditions we all have to Mann up. Brill quotes, L easson learned Hartfelt 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
IMMORTAL HOWDEN ENDER 4,785 Report post Posted July 12 This is all becoming a Bayne in the erse. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
DoofersDad 3,835 Report post Posted July 12 1 hour ago, IMMORTAL HOWDEN ENDER said: This is all becoming a Bayne in the erse. Or Proctortitis to use the medical terminology. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Scarlet Pimple 968 Report post Posted July 12 Och! now it seems you may be..... piling …...it on , IHE. And DD...….....I had a pile operation once and I would not recommend it to anyone. Ever! 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Downinthedumps 128 Report post Posted July 12 Something smells of Keogh. Are you lot all on the Charlie?. I’ve had enough I am of to listen to some Doran Doran. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
DoofersDad 3,835 Report post Posted July 12 I should be making a serious response to this thread but I haven't yet even decided on my keeper. It's a bit of a Tuffey. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
TheMantis 1,351 Report post Posted July 24 On 7/9/2019 at 10:22 PM, wynthank15 said: Brill Tokely... Dodds...Meekings...Shinnie Watkins...Christie...Sheerin...Robson Wyness...Stewart Subs: Calder, Mann, Ryan Christie (if I wasn't playing two wide and two up front and two overlapping full backs he would be in) Wilson, Dargo. Picking the best players in their positions doesn't necessarily produce the best unit. With so many attacking players could possibly do with someone sitting in front of the back four like Warren. PS Don't understand Duncan as meriting a place, great servant and hard worker like Black but couldn't pass accurately beyond his shadow saw too many counter attacks break down with his inability to make a simple pass. Just been watching the Ian Black interview. When asked about the best players during his time here, Russeldinho was the first named followed by Barry. Just saying likes 😉 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
wynthank15 160 Report post Posted July 30 On 7/24/2019 at 9:41 PM, TheMantis said: Just been watching the Ian Black interview. When asked about the best players during his time here, Russeldinho was the first named followed by Barry. Just saying likes 😉 Yes I heard that Mantis I think he might have been referring to his engine and battling qualities certainly wasn't based on his passing ability or vision, he had a foot like a threepny bit but then Black was no great passer either, no argument about Barry who I named as sub behind Watkins for that position even if it is verboten. Can't see Russeldinho being ahead of Christie Snr or Sheerin in terms of creativity or goalscoring but then everyone from fans to Managers have differing opinions. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
TheMantis 1,351 Report post Posted July 30 2 hours ago, wynthank15 said: Yes I heard that Mantis I think he might have been referring to his engine and battling qualities certainly wasn't based on his passing ability or vision, he had a foot like a threepny bit but then Black was no great passer either, no argument about Barry who I named as sub behind Watkins for that position even if it is verboten. Can't see Russeldinho being ahead of Christie Snr or Sheerin in terms of creativity or goalscoring but then everyone from fans to Managers have differing opinions. I reckoned I needed Russeldinho in there in front of the defence ballwinning, not creating. Can't think of anybody better, certainly not Cherry who couldn't play at that level and cost us games by his indiscipline. I had 10cc in the middle for the creativity and Wilson/Robson either side, so sadly no room for Peanut. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
wynthank15 160 Report post Posted August 1 On 7/30/2019 at 10:50 PM, TheMantis said: I reckoned I needed Russeldinho in there in front of the defence ballwinning, not creating. Can't think of anybody better, certainly not Cherry who couldn't play at that level and cost us games by his indiscipline. I had 10cc in the middle for the creativity and Wilson/Robson either side, so sadly no room for Peanut. I think I said in my previous post picking whom you consider to be the best player in each position doesn't necessarily produce the best team so can't disagree with your picks from a team perspective Mantis, I actually mentioned Warren in a sitting role in front of the back four but that's what makes it interesting (and difficult) everyone has a different view coming from a different angle. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
