Sophia, thats your opinion and you are entitled to it, just as others are entitled to their opinions.
I think you are unfairly generalising about people on here. Rosscoe has had nothing but praise on this board for years and this is pretty much the first season where his ability has ever been called into question.
I would agree that some people are perhaps guilty of forgetting that he did not have a pre-season and that he has also been carrying an injury that might have sidelined other players but the very first post on this thread was someone saying "I gave him stick so now I am giving praise where its due". I would call that a pretty well rounded and honest posting.
We seem to have a few categories of posters on this board
1. Always positive no matter what and players can never do any wrong
2. Usually positive and although hesitant to criticise players, do so from time to time
3. Realistic - give praise where it is due, and criticism where it is due
4. Usually negative and although hesitant to praise players, do so from time to time
5. Always negative no matter what and players can never do any right
It would be nice if we could have a board made up of "3"s and everyone would accept that praise and criticism should be handed out in equal measure where merited, but the truth of the matter is that we have posters in each and every one of those categories and if you are a 1 and they are a 5 you are going to get some heated arguments - it doesnt make you right and them wrong, or vice versa, it just means you have differing opinions which you are entitled to.
oh, and before you ask - I have always been a big fan of Rosscoe so am delighted that he seems to be getting back to his best in the last few games.