Thought it might be interesting to take a poll - Dods or Caff?  You decide.........

because i have eyes

My fear is that Rosscoe can be slow on the turn or off the mark. When ya are steaming forward ya gather pace, strength and momentum. That is Rosscoe's absolute strength - nothing better than seeing the big man in full stride - he is more of an attack minded player. Defending wise his first time tackling and positional sense help him out and how many times have ya seen him appear to be struggling and get there (just) in the end. That is because he is really good at tracking back inside and taking in the angles - You just cannot afford to do that at centreback - the angles are limited.. Fast forwards are always on yer feet,  looking to turn ya and get in behind. And Granty would not be able to cover that - he is also a true centreback and not of the "sweeper" nature. Now Caff is a defence minded player. He is pacy and aware, of a "sweeper" nature and a foil fer Munro. If he could develop his distribution then he would be a much improved player.

My fear is that Rosscoe can be slow on the turn or off the mark. When ya are steaming forward ya gather pace, strength and momentum. That is Rosscoe's absolute strength - nothing better than seeing the big man in full stride - he is more of an attack minded player. Defending wise his first time tackling and positional sense help him out and how many times have ya seen him appear to be struggling and get there (just) in the end. That is because he is really good at tracking back inside and taking in the angles - You just cannot afford to do that at centreback - the angles are limited.. Fast forwards are always on yer feet,  looking to turn ya and get in behind. And Granty would not be able to cover that - he is also a true centreback and not of the "sweeper" nature. Now Caff is a defence minded player. He is pacy and aware, of a "sweeper" nature and a foil fer Munro. If he could develop his distribution then he would be a much improved player.

I can see what you are saying but have to disagree, Rossco has to defend against wingers arguebly the fastest and most skillful players on the park, he has to be quick on the turn or he would get ripped every game.  Dods has been caught out for pace on numerous times this season and one of the main reasons I suggested Rossco as a replacement is because he is so agile, not to mention how dominate a figure he would be in the heart of the defence.  Being a centre half is all about positioning yourself and reading the game so you aren't caught out of position and don't have to chase the game (this would be my only worry about Rossco as a centre half), every team I have ever played for the centre halves have been the slowest players in the squad.

:023: !!hsep gniklat era uoy yllacisab

who has dods been outpaced by this season?

Naismith, Miller and more recently Boyd :006:

Booby Mann - the exception to the rule  ;D

Naismith, Miller and more recently Boyd :006:

And Mcdonald.... for a penalty no less....

boyd never outpaced him, if he was faster than dods then he wouldve been clear

watch the video on youtube

:015:

give up!

The couple of times that I've seen Tokely playing centre back have persuaded me that he plays right back or nowhere at all.

Im gonna answer all the questions currently ongoing on this thread.

a) Who would i rather have in the team disregarding contract issues - Dods by a mile. Hes' made the centre half spot his own, is dominant in the air and scores extra goals to.

b) who should play between now and end of season - Caff. We'll never know if he is going to cut the mustard if he isnt played for an extended run and given that Dods is offski then he deserves a chance.

c) Rossco is a right back end of. I'd hate to see him wasted at CB and miss his excellent runs down the right flank.

good answers captain

You have done well in this test.

:021: And he basically simplified what I had expanded on.  :023: