Ok, I haven't read every single response on this thread but here's my view on matters (for what it is worth!)
The site (forum content) has no doubt gone severely downlhill over the past few years and it is far from an enjoyable place to be compared to what it used to be like.
I don't think limiting people to a few posts when they first register is a good idea, i think it'd take new people too long to feel a part of things. My first few posts were mostly humour based and I got into chats with a few folk straight away. If you cannot reply you cannot really be a part of things.
As for getting younger posters to use a seperate forum i feel this too is not a good idea. We didn't need to do this in the past so there is no need we should do now. Besides I'm neither an old duffer (yet) or 'yoof' so where does this leave folk like me?
I feel the answer is pretty simple yet will certainly p1ss a few people off.
In short - just ban the @rseh0les.
There are too many people on this site who think it is acceptable to give the mods lots of work and throw abuse about wherever they want. How, why and when this attitude developed does not matter. If someone does not agree with you it does not mean you start dishing out personal abuse - try that in a pub and see what happens.
I think a system should be put in place along the lines off:
- You get one warning
- after this you get banned for a month
- after this if you still havent learned your lesson you get banned for 3 months
- if your still being an erse then you are banned for life.
No appeals process or anything - there is a perfectly good moderation team here who are not heavy handed.
Too many people add nothing positive to this site merely take away from it and leave a bad atmosphere.
Sadly if the site stays the way it is and Scotty decides it's coming offline then the way things currently are I wouldn't really be too bothered and that is a very sad state of affairs.
Scotty and Don - you have both put far too much time and effort into this site over the years to let a small group of idiots spoil it for the majority. Stand up for yourselves and get hard with folk, this shouldn't be a depressing chore for you.
This may seem harsh but sometimes you have to cut out a cancer to save the rest.