Look folks - no matter what you think of the man, he is paid a very fat salary for the role he performs. He should be judged on various football aspects some of which are as follows:
Team performance
Sound connections UK wide to source players (agents, scouts, opposite numbers at other clubs etc)
Selection of Team Manager
Performance of Team Manager
Player Contracts
Transfers In and Out
Youth Development
I would presume his line manager is the Chairman who should be constantly monitoring his performance (not as Sutherland did, just letting him have a free role because he had no ineterest/knowledge)
Make your own minds up as to his performance and future!