TBH I'm not fussed if he stays or goes. He won us the first division, got us to the challenge cup final and kept us in the SPL for 2 seasons. I'd say he has achieved about par for what we would expect.
On our first season back in the SPL, we were in 3/4th just behind Celtic and Rangers until Christmas, it all went a bit flat in the new year and we ended up in the bottom 6. Same could happen this year, I actually think a bit of a shake up would do us the world of good.
On the other hand, he is a top bloke and the players obviously really enjoy working with the guy, that would be a far bigger miss than anything he brings as a coach. He superb at bringing through young players aswell, its been forced on him but theres not been that many misjudgements, certainly no more than anybody else would make.
Being this is winter, I'd much rather he stayed, he should take a chance on us finishing in a decent league position and maybe winning a trophy before looking at his options in the summer. Until then hes won nothing, maybe for his own sake he should take the bigger contract while its on offer?
I'd imagine the length of the deal theyre offering will be the biggest factor in his decision making, he won't leave for a 1 year deal no matter the salary.