OK I'll play. It is impossible to compare like for like of course, and we would have to say that any of the SPL squads would be able to hammer any of the previous ones, but where's the fun in that. So we just have to pick out our faves from the past and hope they all gel together. So I have put their best years against their names...
Calder 2000)
Tokely 2004, Mann 2003, Mann 1997, Golabek 2001
Cherry 1998, Black 2008, Sheerin 2001, Robson 2003
Wyness 2002, Dargo 2004
Subs - Wilson 2000, Brown 2004, Shearer 2003, Rankin 2006, Brewster 2006.
Haven't bothered checking to dates, so sue me.