Nonsense , McGhee won the league with Reading , took Wolves to the play-offs and an F.A. cup semi final , won the league with Milwall and took them to the play-offs the next season , he also won promotion with Brighton . Not a bad record and 1 our own Terry Butcher would be envious of . Your judging MacGhee on his short spell at Aberdeen .
He was also sacked by Wolves, relegated with Brighton, and is frowned upon at Reading for ditching them for Wolves.
Plus this was about Scottish clubs, he was a good manager at Motherwell but at Aberdeen (granted with very little help by his board) has inherited a decent squad but managed to put them on a downward spiral. Jimmy Calderwood left due to his struggle to get Aberdeen into Europe, they were close to getting dragged into a relegation fight this season.
He may'be isn't the worst manager in Scotland but he certainly isn't one of the better ones.