Just home from the game. I can confirm that we won (just how vitriolic would this thread be if we hadn't?)), but there were sighs of relief all round.
Thimgs started well : the pub was fine, fish & chips excellent, and smokies braw. Then we went to the game.
We did actually start quite well, and to be honest looked very comfortable at half time, no concerns at all. Excellent, composed goal from Vigurs (with his family there to watch), cancelled out immediately by a shot from the edge of the box that deflected off Duff's challenge and looped over the keeper.
Wood turned and poked home a loose ball to put us in front, and despite a deterioration in perfomance we still looked more likely than Arbroath to score again. Barry almost did, ghosting past 3 defenders along the edge of the box before forcing the keeper into a good parry. Most unexpected moment of the game was when Djebi-Zadi lauched himself into an overhead kick from 20 yards, made good contact and got it on target.
The pairing of Wood and McAllister (Rory, oh dear oh dear) had been ineffective all game, and I thought replacing them with Rooney and Barrowboy would finish the game off, but they weren't much better. Barrowman did nothing, other than get booked for kicking the ball away and then get a second yellow after the brawl. Worrying.
Arbroath kept pushing forward and had a half decent penalty claim turned down, but then got awarded one when they clearly shouldn't have. An Arbroath fan I was talking to at the end admitted it was never a pen, but was adamant that the first claim should have been given.
All through extra-time we were just terrible, truly awful. Teamwork, shape and discipline were poor, and Rossco did not contribute much in the way of leadership.
Looking for positives :
1) All 4 penalties were very well taken
2) Vigurs did well
3) Couldn't fault Esson, who made a couple of good saves
4) Black and Wilson showed their class
Negatives :
1) Nothing upfront
2) McGuire and Duff each failed to deal with a simple through ball and let a player through on goal each time
3) Some very erratic passes/crosses from Zadi. A simple 10 yard pass under no presuure nearly went into the North Sea.
All in all, we all felt lucky and relieved to have made it through that one.