Skip to content

Arbroath at home Saturday

Bottoms Up

 

After the Morton madness, it's bottom club Arbroath's turn to benefit from our problems. As if injuries were not bad enough, we appear to have a conflict at the club known as Ridgers Rift and the possibility that could add another name to the missing list. It is however mildly reassuring to note that the Smokies have injury problems of their own plus the manager player conflict known in this case as the Nick Low Law. This game is on Saturday afternoon with a scheduled kick-off time of 3:00pm at the Caledonian Stadium where we will find out if the power of management trumps fan power.

 

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

MATCH/TICKET INFO :ictscarf:

NEW DIRECTOR STATEMENT 👀

QUEENS PARK LATER KICK OFF 

 

Venue Pld Won Drn Lst For Agst + / -
Home 22 16 3 3 56 18 +38
Away 21 9 6 6 26 22 +4
Neutral 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 43 25 9 9 82 40 +42

Only three defeats at home from twenty two matches, although the tide seems to be levelling out over recent fixtures. The legendary Alan Hercher will be resting uneasy at our recent run given how he led the way with a twenty minute hat-trick in August 1994.

CTO report by Ian Broadfoot: 5-2. Caledonian Thistle's Scottish League debut resulted in a tremendous performance and a fine victory. Alan Hercher was the hat-trick hero as Caley Thistle got their League campaign off to a flying start. Three first half goals by Hercher set the scene for a dramatic opening League 3 encounter. In the opening minutes Caley Thistle 'keeper Mark McRitchie had to look sharp to save a 15 yard drive from John Reilly. In 13 minutes Mark McAllister won a corner and Alan Hercher headed in Graeme Bennett's kick to score Caley Thistle's first ever Scottish League goal. It was not long before he also scored the second and third! Before that Arbroath came close on two occasions -the first when a John Brock header went inches past the post and the second when a 25 yard free kick almost found the net. John Scott and Mike Andrew had chances for the home side before Alan Hercher again wrote his name into the record books. In 31 minutes he shot home his second goal through a ruck of players then headed home another corner in 33 minutes.
Half Time: 3-0
In the second half Arbroath came back into it and scored through Brock and Reilly - Caley Thistle bounced back and scored twice more. In 71 minutes Paul McKenzie latched onto a long McRitchie clearance and lobbed over the keeper then Wilson Robertson completed the scoring six minutes later with a high ball from 22 yards.

Full Time: 5-2

This rounded off an exciting match and an historic occasion for both the club and Inverness.

 

Last 10 Competitive Meetings
draw.png
0 - 0
(A)
draw.png
0 - 0
(A)
draw.png
0 - 0
(H)
win.png
3 - 0
(H)
draw.png
0 - 0
(A)
loss.png
0 - 1
(H)
win.png
1 - 0
(A)
win.png
1 - 0
(H)
draw.png
1 - 1
(A)
win.png
3 - 1
(H)

Honours are even over the last six meetings with four draws and a win apiece. The last three fixtures failed to produce a goal over ninety minutes. Given our problems, it's a fair bet that goals will be hard to come by again this weekend. Gone are the days of 7-0 thrashings over the Smokies with Dick Campbell proving to be an astute leader in the face of adversity.

Pos Team Pld W D L F A Pts
 
1. Ayr United 13 7 3 3 28 17 24
2. Morton 13 6 3 4 19 13 21
3. Queens Park 13 6 3 4 21 21 21
4. Inverness CT 13 6 3 4 15 15 21
5. Partick Thistle 13 6 2 5 25 24 20
6. Dundee 13 5 4 4 21 18 19
7. Raith Rovers 13 6 1 6 16 13 19
8. Cove Rangers 13 3 4 6 20 24 13
9. Hamilton Ac. 13 2 5 6 13 24 11
10. Arbroath 13 2 4 7 8 17 10

FRIDAY 4TH NOVEMBER (7:45)

Cove Rangers v Queen's Park

SATURDAY 5TH NOVEMBER (3:00)

 Ayr Utd v Morton

Inverness v Arbroath

   Partick v Dundee

Rovers v Accies

Last Time Out

Our problems were there for all to see on telly last Friday as our makeshift XI shot themselves in the foot by gifting Morton a three goal start at Cappielow. To compound that the Ridgers Rift came into play as Billy hooked Mark at the interval in a sort of public hanging that appears to have been brewing over the last few weeks. Certainly there looks to be a difference of opinions on display at the very least. Mark has been our saviour on numerous occasions, but a couple of errors early on saw Morton go two ahead before David Carson headed into his own net before half time. It was a bizarre game as we dominated possession but looked fragile at the back with numerous big players missing. Up front we were as believable as Boris Johnston and Liz Truss rolled into one. The fourth goal just reinforced this. However, how necessary was the Ridgers Rift?

Arbroath find themselves at the foot of the table after a poor start to the season with only two wins in their opening thirteen games. Last week they went down 2-0 to Ayr United who now top the table. They played with last years player of the championship Michael McKenna chasing shadows as a lone striker with Bobby Linn supporting when he could. The Nick Low Law saw him not on the team sheet. The previous week they beat Accies 1-0. It's been a crazy league so far with any team capable of taking the points off anyone else. They have perked up recently with draws against Queens Park and Dundee, but this was always going to be a difficult season for them after the high of the last one. Unfortunately, we like to bend over backwards to accommodate struggling teams and in fact are one ourselves just now.

Latest Team News

Despite our embarrassing performance last Friday, it was good to have Sean Welsh and Wallace Duffy back on the park. Max Ram is also getting up to speed and maybe Austin Samuels will be next to come off the list. Choice of goalkeeper will come down to the Ridgers Rift which is not ideal for Dodds, Ridgers, Cammy Mackay, the team, the sponsors or the supporters. Let's see what Billy makes of it now.

 

Eric's Smokies surprises

Arbroath have their own injury list to contend with. Missing recently have been defender Tam o'Brien, wide player Scott Stewart and striker Dale Hilson who was kept on the bench last week. Scott Bitsindou on loan from Livingston looked to have done his hamstring as he pulled up after an hour against Ayr United and will likely miss this game. Bin man Linn is the one constant for Arbroath, still performing well even at 76 years of age. Scot Allan will make them tick over in midfield and will need close attention.

At Gayfield Park in the back line its out with the old and in with the new with defender Jason Thomson at 35 years leaving for Kelty Hearts, and Marcel Oakley coming in on loan from Birmingham U21 aged 19 years.

In the middle of the park James Craigen has left for FC Edinburgh and Nicky Low out on loan to Kelty Hearts. Incomers are Scott Bitsindou defensive midfielder on loan from Livingston who went through Belgian club Anderlecht's Youth system. Central midfield player Dylan Tait is on loan from Hibernian. Scott Allan who had a successful loan spell at the Caledonian Stadium is now an ex-Hibernian player who has signed on at Arbroath on a contract until May 2024.

Centre forward Luke Donnelly has vacated Gayfield to further his career at Alloa FC. Kareem Isiaka whose agent describes him as an "attacking" centre forward (is there any other kind?), it transpires he was once with Charlton Athletic FC U21 has signed a short-term contract until January. At 21 years old since being at Charlton his career has been sporadic, last at Vikingur in Iceland.

  • Replies 74
  • Views 12.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Highlight of the game was Mason Hancock getting booed after he was announced as Matt Hancock.

  • snorbens_caleyman
    snorbens_caleyman

    You'll still be in time for the 5.30pm kick-off Toodle-pip!

  • If we had all of the squad fit, I wonder how many of Saturday's starting line up would have been starting - and in the position they played?  Not very many, that's for sure.  Missing the central pairi

Posted Images

Featured Replies

I say,

Next Saturday between 3pm and 4.45pm one is going to sit and watch paint dry.

That will stir up the same level of excitement in me as going to ICT home matches these days. 

Edge of the seat stuff!!

Eh what? 🧐 

 

6 minutes ago, No Shin Guards said:

Next Saturday between 3pm and 4.45pm one is going to sit and watch paint dry.

You'll still be in time for the 5.30pm kick-off :ictscarf:

Toodle-pip!

Absolutely awful football and fed up of the excuses BD will come out with. Coaching between the 3 of them has a lot to be desired these days and so very hard to watch . Another wasted season it looks like unless the club act NOW and not waste any more time.in getting shot of them . He clearly is upsetting his own players and things will get far worse no doubt .  It’s a lot of his players playing week in and week out and his tactics which clearly are not working ! BD is  Very Very lucky to have kept his job after last years mid season shambles and scraping playoffs really kept him in office . For me last year he had to go.

Now he really has to go and fast!

Show some ambition and balls chairman. 

1 minute ago, caley1 said:

Absolutely awful football and fed up of the excuses BD will come out with. Coaching between the 3 of them has a lot to be desired these days and so very hard to watch . Another wasted season it looks like unless the club act NOW and not waste any more time.in getting shot of them . He clearly is upsetting his own players and things will get far worse no doubt .  It’s a lot of his players playing week in and week out and his tactics which clearly are not working ! BD is  Very Very lucky to have kept his job after last years mid season shambles and scraping playoffs really kept him in office . For me last year he had to go.

Now he really has to go and fast!

Show some ambition and balls chairman. 

Small squad. players out same rubbish as the last few weeks.

Only two subs used today. Give the young ones on a bench a chance. Tokely has spoken highly off the talent we have coming through at the moment even if it's for last 10 mins it's getting the game time and also giving out 1st players a break.

  • Author

Match overview.........

Defensive Lapse

 

Inverness dropped to fifth in the table after a defensive lapse cost them all three points. Bottom club Arbroath had their task made easier with Dodds dropping Mark Ridgers to the bench. In a first half of few chances McKenna hit the post with a curling effort for the visitors with the keeper stranded. Doran curled a similar effort just over with Gaston stranded as Inverness grew into the game before the interval. Despite some home pressure, the final pass was always a touch too many and it was goalless at the break. Nathan Shaw opened the scoring after he met a flick on at the back post. Having worked hard to get ahead we gifted Arbroath a leveller after a wayward defensive header left Kieran Shanks through on goal to drill past a helpless Mackay. Gaston pulled off some tremendous saves from Harper, Duffy and Mckay and Arbroath finished with a wee flourish, but we held on for a point.

First half instantly forgettable.Showed more desire and tempo second half and flashes of some nice football.Said it before, Mackay and Oakley don't work up front.Thought we would go 4 5 1

Individual defensive error cost us 3 points.

Thought Shaw had one of his better games.Thats about it other than amazing that we are only 3 points off top.

We could have been a couple up by half time,but credit to their goalkeeper he had some good saves.

Overall,better than last week though that would no be hard,but think we have to remember that we are 9 first team lads down,so the fact we are in the mix still is good.Imagine if we had a full team.

Edited by Douglas Mackenzie

3 minutes ago, Douglas Mackenzie said:

First half instantly forgettable.Showed more desire and tempo second half and flashes of some nice football.Said it before, Mackay and Oakley don't work up front.Thought we would go 4 5 1

Individual defensive error cost us 3 points.

Thought Shaw had one of his better games.Thats about it other than amazing that we are only 3 points off top.

Again

3 hours ago, snorbens_caleyman said:

Depends on what his ambitions and circumstances are - I simply don't know.  He is still only 25 - young for a goalkeeper - so I would guess that he could well still be hoping for first-team football somewhere.

His wife is expecting and he seems really settled imho. This drama is not needed. 

I thought we were much better today than last week and created plenty chances, and should have taken several of them, with at least four decent saves from the Arbroath ‘keeper and several cases in the first half when players passed rather than taking good shooting opportunities.

We had 9 attempts on target out of 14 in total and on a different day would (and should) have won that comfortably.

When we went in front it was in a spell when we were totally dominant, but an error by Carson gifted Arbroath the equaliser and thereafter they pressed us back a bit.

I don’t know if we have a problem off the park (hopefully not and it is just that Ridgers’ form has dropped a bit) but I thought we had several key players who were low on confidence in the first half which meant they did not take shots on, with Mckay and Doran standing out for me in that regard. With the ball skidding off the pitch the way it was, it was a game calling out for shots on goal.

Mckay had two goal bound headers saved well, Duffy had one saved and I’ve no idea how the ‘goalie kept another goal bound effort out.

With 8 players out and only 2 points out of the last 12, we are only 3 points off the top, so if we can get players back and / or start taking our chances,   we can still be right in contention.

Everyone else is slipping up too, which is helping us.

MacKay had no chance with the goal or the one that hit the post, and there was less route 1 from him.

Other than Carson’s mistake, the defence was pretty secure, with Duffy starting a few forward moves whilst Delaney continues to catch the eye.

Welsh was more like his old self, whilst I didn’t realise Scott Allan was on the park until he was hooked. Harper was looking to get shots away, but not his best game this season.

Shaw had probably his best game for us and followed in well for the goal. Doran sometimes did take players on but seemed a bit shot shy. Mckay worked hard and could have had a hat trick but seemed reluctant to shoot in the first half. Oakley did what Oakley does but strayed offside too often.

To sum up, better but still not good enough, but we are in touch and should be capable of climbing the league.

Shooting practice is needed before next Saturday’s game.

43 minutes ago, Yngwie said:

Having the majority of the first team unavailable is pretty darn legitimate as far as excuses go.

Tbh there wasn't much wrong with that team. I think the system was at fault 

Nathan Shaw was by far our best option going forward.

Cannot believe we are still playing one of our most physical central midfield players at right back and our left back in central midfield. Absolutely criminal we never replaced Rooney and that is one f**ck up Dodds cant dodge.

5 minutes ago, old caley girl said:

Tbh there wasn't much wrong with that team. I think the system was at fault 

Can say the exact same for the Morton game

2 minutes ago, forresjags said:

and our left back in central midfield.

Delaney is a better left back than Harper, who seems to be revelling in the midfield role. I can see him settling into a left sided attacking role once we have more options available to us.

I agree we need bite in midfield. Welsh being back is helping but we are really missing Allardice.

Some updates from the club about how long players will be out for would be helpful. 

18 minutes ago, old caley girl said:

Tbh there wasn't much wrong with that team. I think the system was at fault 

The system that served up so many chances and only beat the keeper once?

You could tell where Arbroath are in the league by the number of clear chances we created agsibst them in the second half. Most other teams in the division would have put two or three of these chances away.

 

 

Gaston got Arbroath a point today along with Carson's rush of blood to the head 🙈  Not convinced about dropping Ridgers. It will all come out in the wash hopefully. Good to see Welsh back. Still all to play for. Dust them down and see who is standing for next week and go again. Bish bash bosh. ....

Only better because we managed to scrape a point against the bottom team in the division. Who by the way looked so much fitter,  stronger and battered us in the last 15 minutes.

 

 

 

22 minutes ago, forresjags said:

Only better because we managed to scrape a point against the bottom team in the division. Who by the way looked so much fitter,  stronger and battered us in the last 15 minutes.

 

 

 

Totally agree. 

17 minutes ago, tm4tj said:

 

😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴

Agree that we ought to have won that today. Is that not what makes football endlessly interesting that we didn't. Now then now then 😁 ha ha. Be unique just like everyone else... Good effort in the circumstances and I will go on record as saying well done men. Bring it on...😃

2 hours ago, tm4tj said:

 

🤮🤮🤮

It was a better display than the Morton fiasco, but that wouldn't be hard. Dodds again plays the wrong system, he is a clueless tactician. He went with Mckay and Oakley up front again! That obviously didn't work against Morton, so why persist with it? Mckay works his socks off, as he does constantly, and was unlucky not to score on a couple of occasions, but I just don't think Oakley gives us enough to justify his place in the eleven. What we needed was more in midfield, and I was surprised to see Boyd dropped to the bench, as he looked quite bright against Morton. We played our best football when we got the ball down and passed it at pace, our goal came from such a move, but too many times we reverted to Hoofball, and you could see Mckay's frustration when the CB kept beating him in the air.

Carson did slip up for their goal, but I still think Dodds is at fault for this, he has never replaced Rooney, and that's a few seasons now. Carson is a combative box to box midfielder, who was put in at RB when we had no cover there, and because he played quite well, Dodds seems to think that we don't need to look for a RB now! With Allardice out, the midfield needs to be strong and flexible, and we do miss Carson playing on his actual position, it must be frustrating for him.

Shaw was my MOTM, his best game for ICT, I thought Delaney again stood out, and Welsh gives us that cool head in the middle of the park.

I have said on many occasions that Dodds was the easy choice for the club, just as Robbo was. The criteria for the managers job seems to be, are you a coach? Do you live locally? You're hired. So, are there any other coaches about who live in the area? And does anyone know when Dodds contract runs to?

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. : Terms of Use : Guidelines : Privacy Policy

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.