As he has already got the job we may as well start looking at his positives:

1. His training and diet regimes had our team playing at the height of their capabilities.

2. Many of the players will welcome him back and will "play" FOR him.

3. Niculae WILL benefit. Niculae is a Brewster-esque type of player - but potentially better. If he plays in the old Brew role, as coached by the man himself, he could be a major asset. At the moment he doesnt fit into the system or vice versa.

I am reliably informed that these are the reasons - especially 3.

4) He will fit in well at the Heathmount...

I have not posted on this site for a **** of a long time but the thought of Brewster returning has got to me  To put it simply, he can get to FECK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

He left after all the loyalty rubbish and then made a complete mess at United.

Brewster  :33:

Hey GJ  :sillywave:

5) We kept the CB training gear...no added cost there.

back at ya!

Charlie Brown also fits CB and I would take him before Brewster.  With Snoopy on the coaching staff!

5) We kept the CB training gear...no added cost there.

so give the job to Charlie Bannerman !!!

ps - welcome back GJ

PS  How much is it going to cost us in transfer/compensation money to Aberdeen?

I will carry on backing the team, just not the manager.

Case against:-

He's a w@nker and a cr@p manager!!!

Well said QB!

Dull uninspiring unambitious choice, will make a lot of people angry (including myself)

I think this thread should be renamed Taxi for Brewster......

Case against:-

He's a w@nker and a cr@p manager!!!

He's no' that good

Right now we need an actual manager, someone who can actually do the job.  Brewster is not that person.

QB why dont you just say what you REALLY think  :015:

I think this thread should be renamed Taxi for Brewster......

Sorry but Paul Sheerin already has it booked to take him to the Legends' Night.

After reading some of the stuff on this forum, Brewster may not want to return.

Lets hope so!

Good!!

Just wondering, does the club shop still have a stock of those pink "Brewster's Babes" t-shirts? Or did they get punted off to Tannadice in the back of Proctor's car?

Just wondering, does the club shop still have a stock of those pink "Brewster's Babes" t-shirts? Or did they get punted off to Tannadice in the back of Proctor's car?

LMAO!

Although I'd also prefer Brewster to return I think he's probably the best choice out of the 3 previous managers if one of them is going to get the job (Warnock is just a pipedream me thinks).

He also made a great signing in Dargo.

Realistically if Warnock is out of the equation who would you rather take the job than Brewster bearing in mind it will be VERY hard to attract a lot of guys up here?

its seems pretty certain brew will get it and i for one hope bennet and co. read this forum and this threat in particualr because i want them to know from me personally that i will be extremely disappointed in thier small minded thinking and want them to make a apology for all the fans who obviously wasted their time at the meeting last night!

The only case I want to see for Brewster is one of the 'suit' variety so we could watch it sliding down the luggage belt as he heads for the departure lounge at Dalcross

What really puzzles me is the fact there are so many supporters who favour Brewster.

I understand the reasoning of folk who don't want him back because of the 'loyalty' issue but the real concern for me is purely the footballing side.

As mentioned elsewhere there seems to be a real better-the-devil-you-know mentality being shown by some fans.

If Brewster hadn't been our manager before and was being judged purely on his DUFC record how could anyone possibly take him seriously.

Time and again I hear how fit he got the team. Are we really that unfit now? Fair enough if the team they can run all day but without tactics and a gameplan to back that up it doesn't really matter

Other arguments I've heard coming from the Pro-Brewster camp are

1.) How organised we were! Fair enough we were but it was dull as **** to watch. Trying to beat teams on the counter attack at home produced truly rubbish football to watch. It was a great idea away from home and worked well but it seemed to be our ONLY tactic

2. He's more experienced now!! Aye at losing :023:

3.) He wouldn't be so quick to leave us again. This is the one that truly stumps me. The nature of football is that the better you do the higher up the food chain you go whether that be as a player or manager. If you are doing well you attract attention from bigger fish that's always been the way of it and always will.  If he's doing well there is no way that Brewster would turn down a move to say Celtic or Rangers is they came knocking 18 months down the line

I just had a nasty message confirming that he is the man.  Can someone confirm this confirmation?

We need a real manager to keep ICT in the SPL.  Warnock is the man, I believe who can do that not Craig "I can't manage" Brewster .

Just wondering, does the club shop still have a stock of those pink "Brewster's Babes" t-shirts? Or did they get punted off to Tannadice in the back of Proctor's car?

I've still got mine  :004:  Never throw anything away, you just never know when it might come in handy.  :015: :015: :015:

I just had a nasty message confirming that he is the man.  Can someone confirm this confirmation?

Yes - three feckin months ago - and I can also confirm that Donald Park will resign and Duncan Shearer will be appointed in his place - also three months ago.

1.) How organised we were! Fair enough we were but it was dull as **** to watch. Trying to beat teams on the counter attack at home produced truly rubbish football to watch. It was a great idea away from home and worked well but it seemed to be our ONLY tactic

I'd take being dull as **** over relegation.  I think that we are seeing reverse rose-tinted spectacle syndrome regarding Brewsters brand of football.  We produced some fantastic displays when he was manager.  4-1 v Livingston, 2-0 Hearts, 3-2 v Dundee in the top six 'decider', wins over Hibs, the televised game against Celtic where we gave the eventual champions a pummelling and almost took the points.  Listening to some posters on here you'd think that we drew every game 0-0.  It was Brewster who gave Ian Black hsi debut in the side and signed Craig Dargo.

2. He's more experienced now!! Aye at losing :023:

Brewster will have gained experience at Tannadice, he had to deal with different players, different situations and he will (hopefully!) have learned from the harsh experience he had there.

3.) He wouldn't be so quick to leave us again. This is the one that truly stumps me. The nature of football is that the better you do the higher up the food chain you go whether that be as a player or manager. If you are doing well you attract attention from bigger fish that's always been the way of it and always will.  If he's doing well there is no way that Brewster would turn down a move to say Celtic or Rangers is they came knocking 18 months down the line

That is true of any manager.  If we appointed Warnock it would be more of a factor - clubs from all levels of English football can probably offer more money than us and if he had even a few montsh of success teams from the Championship would be sniffing around him.  As a smaller club with fewer resources than a lot of our rivals that is something we will have to deal with.

One factor is that we are in a dire situation NOW.  We can't afford for a manager to spend time getting to know the players.  After the Dundee utd game we play Hibs, Celtic and Hearts - we are in a dire situation and need to get going soon.  Brewster knows the players (10 of the 13 who played on Saturday played under him) and can hopefully slot in without disruption.