Player of the Year Poll - St Johnstone

[Scotty]

*** VOTING IN THE POLL ABOVE IS FOR PEOPLE WHO WERE AT THE MATCH ONLY ***

If you were at the match, please use the poll above to vote for your top 3 players.

As a bit of fun, we have also added an option to rate the referee ....

 

Please make sure you vote for 3 separate players.

 

If you make an error, let us know so we can fix it.

PLEASE ONLY VOTE ABOVE IF YOU WERE AT THE GAME

Anyone caught trying to cheat the system WILL be banned from voting in ALL site polls...this is your only warning.

---

 

**NOT at the game ?**

As a result of requests received, we have made a slight change to how these threads work for site users who watched the game on TV or listened to the full game live on the radio .......

You too will now be able to cast your votes, but should do it in the thread below, and NOT in the official poll above. Just list the three players of your choosing and award 5,3, or 1 point(s). You can give the ref a mark if you want too !

These votes will NOT be counted in the official total, as we only count votes from those who where actually at the game, but it IS a way for you to participate in the process .... which many people asked for .... a happy medium we hope !!!!!

---

[tm4tj]

Reguero getting votes for going to Killie?  Had nothing to do during the game other than cut out a couple of crosses.  Mannus made a couple of excellent saves.

[Yngwie]

Reguero didn't put a foot wrong, and made a really good save down low in the 1st half.

[tm4tj]

Nah, routine stuff, although his handling was good, not deserving of points though, unlike Meekings who was once again superb, strong and fast, another good night for Josh.

[Yngwie]

Yeah Meekings followed by OTJ, IMO.

[Rainbow]

Meekings

Reguero

Draper

 

Ref was surprisingly good

[Bluesman]

Meekings, Draper, Reguero.

 

Highlights made it look a better game than it actually was. Too often at home we've seen the first ten minutes look promising then poor passing and decision making ruins the game. The performance succeeded in silencing our own fans by the end.

 

The midfield just isnt working as good as it was pre Jan break. OTJ ok going forward but far too casual in midfield role. We had too many sideways passes and too slack at marking opposing midfield - that's how we lost to Hearts in the cup. The two forward passes we did have both almost resulted in goals.

 

Other results went for us again today - so not as costly as it could have been. For me, we need to pick up the pace and direction in the middle of the park again.

Edited April 6, 2013 by Bluesman

[Huisdean]

 

Nah, routine stuff, although his handling was good, not deserving of points though, unlike Meekings who was once again superb, strong and fast, another good night for Josh.

 You're a hard man to please tm4j. I voted Reguero for 3 points as felt his handling was first class, he was alert throughout the game and gave the defence confidence throughout the game.

[RiG]

Meekings

Draper

OTJ

[tm4tj]

 

Nah, routine stuff, although his handling was good, not deserving of points though, unlike Meekings who was once again superb, strong and fast, another good night for Josh.

 You're a hard man to please tm4j. I voted Reguero for 3 points as felt his handling was first class, he was alert throughout the game and gave the defence confidence throughout the game.

 

Maybe so, but he really only made 1 routine save plus some excellent handling, not to mention some poor clearances.  Overall for me he never merited points, but that is my opinion.  Meekings was and has been great all season.  When a young defender can hold his own against opposition strikers without his normal sidekick then he has done well.  Draper, Foran, McKay all worked hard as well and Doran sometimes flatters to deceive but is a handful for most defences, would like to see him add some goals.

 

I also thought Raven had one of his poorer games by recent standards, he misplaced the ball a number of times early in the game but like Devine got better as the clock ticked forward.

 

I wonder what Shane has done wrong to merit Nick Ross getting on the pitch before him?

 

I did leave disappointed by the result and the performance.  I don't think we have had a proper go at St Johnstone this season, and unless we change something in the next encounter, then I can't see us doing any better, although a point next time might well be a better point given the circumstances at the time.  As it turned out on the Saturday, that point was a good one after all.

[WYNESS101]

Meekings

 

OTJ

 

Reguero