McCaffrey or McGuire

[ekjules]

Do you think that McCaffrey should get his place back in the starting eleven, or should he stick with McGuire. :024: I was surprised he was dropped for the celtic game.

[wyness_is_god]

Stick with McGuire, Caff just is not good enough although would love to be proved wrong.

[tm4tj]

If Caff is fit I would go with him, not seen enough of McGuire to put him ahead of Caff, who has been our best defendefr on occasions this year.  The old Caff is getting back in the zone.

[Strathman]

Prefer Caff.  Anyone seen how Guy Kerr is doing in the reserves?

[clacher_holiday2]

McGuire gets stuck in, most important quality in a defender when under pressure, I'd have him in ahead of Caff.

How about them both ahead of Munro?

[Libero]

McGuire gets stuck in, most important quality in a defender when under pressure, I'd have him in ahead of Caff.

How about them both ahead of Munro?

interesting suggestion, grant hasnt regained his form of last season, been caught out quite a few times and given away a couple of pens, i think dropping him would do more harm than good though, out of caff and mcguire i'd be inclined to go with mcguire but would like to see watt  given a chance

[L_G]

Caff for me please

[true jaggy]

thought mcguire had a good game today

[MacBandy]

Thought McGuire did a really sound job of being in the right place at the right time today. Doesn't do anything spectacular but doesn't need to. Stops them from having the time to get a shot off as he is always there. He seems more in tune with Granty to. Half the prob with Caff is that he and Granty were getting pulled apart and leaving huge gaps.

McGuire for me- he is no Doddsy but solid and OK for this level.

[Yngwie]

I'm not convinced by either.

[+Tree]

The body language of Grant and Tokely is much better with McGuire than Caff (they obviously trust him much more).

Caff definitely is not the answer and I am not convinced McGuire is either. It is early days for him in the defensive unit. I still think we need someone with a greater physical presence - Nothing can happen on this front until Jan anyway (unless Watt gets fit at least).

[Guest jaggiebunnet]

I would go for Caff but you can,t change a winning team.

Yellow card for McGuire to-day  :32:

Hope it,s not a regular thing. :018:

[TSTtiger]

on this seasons form, would go with mcguire. caff definately does have the ability, however he is essentially coming in as a dods replacement and dont think thats him at all. its not mcguire either but think if caff was playing alongside dods in defence then we'd all be raving about him, but without dods or a dods type which we will still have to buy, he doesn't seem comfortable in the back four we put out, so i guess he's somewhat the fall guy for our short sightedness in getting a bloody central defender in