esson

[strathyjags]

whats everyones thoughts on him? was last nights game a one off or will he keep his place?i have heard from a reliable source fraser isnt happy with the wage hes on and has asked duncan shearer to put feelers out with his contacts about a move,heard how much more cash he wants to stay and it isnt much compared to what some ict bench warmers are one

[DALNEIGHCALEY]

Decent keeper. Think hes been in nets for all the league cup games.

[AJS]

I think technique-wise he is a better keeper than Michael Fraser, he is also more experienced as he has been in the Scotland squad once or twice. I still think Mikey is an excellent keeper though, but i think given that he has made a couple of hashes like Mikolounas goal for Hearts and Connor Sammons for Killie i think Esson deserves a chance.

[Alex MacLeod]

whats everyones thoughts on him? was last nights game a one off or will he keep his place?i have heard from a reliable source fraser isnt happy with the wage hes on and has asked duncan shearer to put feelers out with his contacts about a move,heard how much more cash he wants to stay and it isnt much compared to what some ict bench warmers are one

Ikes contract is up for negotiation so this is the time when he should be talking about money. I'm quite sure he's happy enough where he is. He is the No.1 and Esson was brought in to provide competition. Mike could leave us and never get another opportunity like he has here

Edited October 29, 2008 by Alex MacLeod

[CaleyD]

Fraser is an ok keeper and we could have worse. He's also young and still learning and will, IMO, be a great keeper some day. In saying that though, I don't think he's worth breaking the bank for and I'd far rather see us stretching the budget to secure contracts elsewhere in the squad.

[Yngwie]

I was delighted to see Esson get a start last night, but came away thinking we should stick with Fraser.

[absent friend]

I feel that we are in the strongest position, having Esson as back up.

In goal or on the bench? I feel he should be given an extended run to gel with the back players in a competitive situation and then we will have the best of him. His experience will rub off on the defense, his distribution from his throw outs will create more attacks on the ground, leading to better football from the team. Why is he not being used right now? We need our current goalie's signature on a contract!

Fraser must realise that he has not attracted any attention yet but if he sits where he is and gets a share of the matches, he will then have a chance to showcase himself and perhaps follow his predecessor into the higher earning bracket, in the future.

[Kingsmills]

We are now in the happy position of having two very competent goalkeepers even if neither of them are world beaters. Our problems lie at the other end of the park.

[Govan Jaggie]

Esson looked comfortable last night. Never really had a save to make but dealt with every high ball well. His kicking was good and tried to start attacks quickly. His effort on the Falkirk goalie was impressive also. Give him more games I say.

[davieB]

He's the better of the two in my opinion. His distribution is far better than Michaels.

[The Mantis]

Seen all 3 cup ties and would have no problem if Esson was kept in the team. If anything I think his experience makes him a shade better than Mikey but Mikey has certainly learned a lot over the past 2 years and has time on his side. Also is Esson a bit taller?

[Kingsmills]

Esson probably just shades it with his better and more effective distribution.

[dead_ball_specialist]

I don't rate Fraser at all, he's young but that means nothing. Some goalkeepers don't peak until their mid thirties!

From what I've seen of Esson he reads the game better both in positioning himself in anticipating opponents efforts and in his distribution of the ball.

[Alex MacLeod]

Seen all 3 cup ties and would have no problem if Esson was kept in the team. If anything I think his experience makes him a shade better than Mikey but Mikey has certainly learned a lot over the past 2 years and has time on his side. Also is Esson a bit taller?

Esson 6'1"............Fraser 6' 3"

Difficult to say who'd be the best week on week but Fraser does need to learn how to read the game and when to throw out, kick out or whatever.

P&J Today

[Guest WynessLegend]

Definitely think that Fraser's demands for more money should be completely ignored.

Two reasons for this -

Esson is a better keeper.

No other team would be remotely interested in signing Fraser.

[roby]

Definitely think that Fraser's demands for more money should be completely ignored.

Two reasons for this -

Esson is a better keeper.

No other team would be remotely interested in signing Fraser.

I know what i would be saying to Fraser. That is the contract take it or leave it. The problem with him is he believes he is better than he is. I would have thought with the mistakes he has made this season he would be more humble.I would be surprised if any other s.p.l. club came in for him. Esson is a far more experienced and better all round keeper and deserves a run in the team.

[alimci]

From Alex's P&J link: "?Losing hurts but there is quite a good atmosphere at the stadium."

Is he going to the same games as everyone else?

[AJS]

Knowing Brew it was probably his plan to put Ryan Esson in the starting team. But he wanted to wait and see how Ike gets on. But had it been Brew as manager 2 years ago when Brown left i imagine he may have handled things differently.

[absent friend]

Esson will not get a permanent place until Fraser signs on the dotted line.

If Fraser is dropped/subbed at this time he could react and delay signing, this could have a disruptive reaction in the dressing room.

With Brew having won the dressing room and the spirit in there being up at the moment, why take a chance.

[Alex MacLeod]

Why do people think Esson would be the better keeper. In the two seasons he had at Shrewsbury he played 6 times.

[strathyjags]

whats everyones thoughts on him? was last nights game a one off or will he keep his place?i have heard from a reliable source fraser isnt happy with the wage hes on and has asked duncan shearer to put feelers out with his contacts about a move,heard how much more cash he wants to stay and it isnt much compared to what some ict bench warmers are one

Ikes contract is up for negotiation so this is the time when he should be talking about money. I'm quite sure he's happy enough where he is. He is the No.1 and Esson was brought in to provide competition. Mike could leave us and never get another opportunity like he has here

thats the thing though,hes seeing players playing a bit part on more than twice his wage,so he certainly isnt happy

[CaleyP]

i think esson is a good keeper and makes a great second choice keeper...i think we should count ourselves lucky to have two decent keepers...i think we should stick with ike. ike is doing fine at the moment and will only get better with time. what i find funny is that people on here are questioning ike's possible request for more money...im sorry but every single person in the world would be asking for more money if you were in the same position....starting every game and on half the wage of some very over rated and well past it players. we should be more concerned with some of our out field players that are too old or just dont cut it in the SPL.

[+Tree]

Why do people think Esson would be the better keeper. In the two seasons he had at Shrewsbury he played 6 times.

I think I am right in saying that he was injured for most, or at least a significant part, of his time there

[davieB]

Why do people think Esson would be the better keeper. In the two seasons he had at Shrewsbury he played 6 times.

I always rated him highly when he was at Aberdeen. Quite a few times he single handedly denied us the three points.

In the cup games I've seen him in this season he seems more assured in every department than Michael. His distribution is much better, and he gets the attacks moving far quicker.

[davieB]

Surely Esson has to be given a chance after Frasers display today.