POY Player of the Year - Kilmarnock

[Scotty]

*** VOTING IN THE POLL ABOVE IS FOR PEOPLE WHO WERE AT THE MATCH ONLY ***

If you were at the match, please use the poll above to vote for your top 3 players.
As a bit of fun, we have also added an option to rate the referee ....

Please make sure you vote for 3 separate players.

If you make an error, let us know so we can fix it.

PLEASE ONLY VOTE ABOVE IF YOU WERE AT THE GAME

Anyone caught trying to cheat the system WILL be banned from voting in ALL site polls...this is your only warning.

---

**NOT at the game ?**

As a result of requests received, we have made a slight change to how these threads work for site users who watched the game on TV or listened to the full game live on the radio .......

You too will now be able to cast your votes, but should do it in the thread below, and NOT in the official poll above. Just list the three players of your choosing and award 5,3, or 1 point(s). You can give the ref a mark if you want too !

These votes will NOT be counted in the official total, as we only count votes from those who where actually at the game, but it IS a way for you to participate in the process .... which many people asked for .... a happy medium we hope !!!!!

---

 

[CaleyD]

Dallas wasn't the referee yesterday, it was Nick Walsh.

[rocky1]

1 hour ago, CaleyD said:

Dallas wasn't the referee yesterday, it was Nick Walsh.

His refereeing ability made him look like Dallas . The best referees we had was when they went on strike and the SFA drafted in foreign  refs at least they had no pre conceived ideas of which team should win - not that I am suggesting Walsh was bias he was just a poor referee!

[PerfICT]

Fon Williams: 6 - apart from a poor flap at a cross late on, didn't play badly and very nearly got to the pen.

McKay: 4 - worst game yet and gave away a daft penalty when the cross had been dealt with.

Meekings: 6 - played OK. Picked up a booking "for the team".

Warren: 6 - solid, but his distribution was pretty poor.

Tremarco: 8 - easily our best player in defence and attack.

Mulraney: 5 - a piece of magic in the first half to get away from 3 defenders, followed by a poor final ball. Caught in possession too often thereafter. You can see why Foran is reluctant to play him all the time.

Tansey: 5 - not firing this season and lucky not to be booked. A decent shot in the first half.

Vigurs: 5 - I felt he played better than most on CTO thought. There were a couple of heart-in-mouth moments deep in his own half, but he got a few good moves going.

Polworth: 5 - can't fault him for effort, but he's not a wide midfielder and certainly not on the left. Was always too narrow.

Draper: 5 - strangely quiet, but should not have been subbed.

Doumbaya: 5 - got the goal, but only held the ball up on a couple of occasions. Goes down too easily.

Doran: 7 - made an impact and a few decent shots at goal.

King: 7 - also made a difference.

Bowden: 2 - offered nothing.

Foran: 4 - got this one all wrong. Midfield was a mess. Players substituted off were strange - Draper wasn't his usual, but was ahead of several others. Polworth on the left didn't work. Tansey and Vigurs holding doesn't work. Doumbaya was lucky to stay on, but I suppose decision vindicated by his goal. I suppose Foran should be credited for going for it after subbing Mackay for a striker. I have no idea what our formation was after that, but it worked out!

Ref: 6 - for me, not as bad as some suggest. Penalty was right - clumsy challenge. He missed a few things, but I don't think the challenge on Doumbaya was a pen - there was a stronger case for Warren being clotheslined later.

[Robert]

Not easy this week!

Tremarco

Fon Williams

Doran

 

[WYNESS101]

Tremarco

Fon Williams

Polworth

[RiG]

I see Nick Walsh has rated his own performance in the poll.

[Scotty]

6 hours ago, CaleyD said:

Dallas wasn't the referee yesterday, it was Nick Walsh.

trust me to rely on the BBC report/stats page !

[CaleyD]

1 hour ago, Scotty said:

trust me to rely on the BBC report/stats page !

In fairness, I think that may pull through from Opta as well.....and they have been dire in all regards with our stats this year.  So much so that I think we should stop using them (I have a more reliable option).