Player Ratings

[tm4tj]

County game, my opinion..............

 

Brill: 8 Absolutely solid and pulled off one tremendous save

Raven: 7 First goal and always available

Warren: 7 Another rock solid display

Meekings: 8 As above and some skill and pace

Shinnie: 8 Really coming on to a game, International recognition soon?

Tansey: 7 Has added some bite and skill to midfield

Draper: 7 No nonsense performance from the big man

Doran: 8 Great trickery and control, had the defender on toast

Foran: 9 Immense, and led by example, dictating play from front and back

Vincent 7 Lively performance, should have done better with first half effort, but great box to box midfielder

McKay: 8 Great goal and his awareness is second to none along with his hold up and link play. Not just for Xmas

Watkins: 6 sub and goal

other subs just on 4

 

No failures

[Sneckboy]

Player ratings are such a tabloid thing - one paper gives a 5, another a 7. It's totally subjective. It's all a lot of nonsense anyway.

Unless 'ratings' are standardised they have no value. Every football match, whether the Champions League final or the Junior Cup final should have a finite number of points available. Say 22 players x 5 = 110 points. Logically, the total player points should be identical whatever the match.  

[KeithD]

County game, my opinion..............

 

Brill: 8 Absolutely solid and pulled off one tremendous save

Raven: 7 First goal and always available

Warren: 7 Another rock solid display

Meekings: 8 As above and some skill and pace

Shinnie: 8 Really coming on to a game, International recognition soon?

Tansey: 7 Has added some bite and skill to midfield

Draper: 7 No nonsense performance from the big man

Doran: 8 Great trickery and control, had the defender on toast

Foran: 9 Immense, and led by example, dictating play from front and back

Vincent 7 Lively performance, should have done better with first half effort, but great box to box midfielder

McKay: 8 Great goal and his awareness is second to none along with his hold up and link play. Not just for Xmas

Watkins: 6 sub and goal

other subs just on 4

 

No failures

 

Thank you very much!

 

Player ratings are such a tabloid thing - one paper gives a 5, another a 7. It's totally subjective. It's all a lot of nonsense anyway.

Unless 'ratings' are standardised they have no value. Every football match, whether the Champions League final or the Junior Cup final should have a finite number of points available. Say 22 players x 5 = 110 points. Logically, the total player points should be identical whatever the match.  

 

Player ratings aren't dictating anything in this scenario, they are purely to aid seeing which players played best. In my situation the numerical value is only really useful within the singular game itself and there is no comparison of figures across multiple games. I think what the forum does with "Player of the Year" is a fantastic implementation of a standardised voting system and works a treat, however for the purpose of my data reports the player ratings give a quick oversight of which players performed and which didn't. 

Edited February 27, 2014 by KeithD

[+bughtmaster]

I have a sneaky feeling that a certain D is up to no good I await his punchline.

[KeithD]

Don't think I'll bother asking this week, I think it's fair to say it was a bit of an off day.

[Sneckboy]

But isn't that the whole point of your 'rankings'! For accuracy, surely you can't just pick and choose which games to count or you'll end up with skewed results?!