Managerial Question

[IMMORTAL HOWDEN ENDER]

What is the difference between John Robertson, Charlie Christie and Craig Brewster ?

Robbo readily admiited that he had made a mistake or an error of judgement.  :024:

[KingBeastie]

???

[clacher_holiday2]

Robertson won us 2 trophies and got us into the SPL, he also got us through the Pittodrie spell and to Hampden twice.  He signed Bayne, Dods, Black, Bingham, Proctor and Morgan for free (off the top of my head.. Hastings?  Dargo?  Wyness?) and was the first ICT manager to add a sense of purpose, team spirit and drive to our play.

In terms of admitting errors of judgment, I really cant remember.

In Brewsters current spell, he may have very questionable team selections but so far he appears to make an effort in change things after mistakes, even if he doesnt talk about it openly on Radio Scotland.

[ictchris]

Who cares if managers talk about their mistakes?

Clacher, Brewster signed Morgan, Dargo and Wyness.  I do agree that Robbo was a hugely important manager for us though - he built successfully on the foundations left by Pele.

[Scarlet Pimple]

If Rowan Alexander can get the can at Gretna after winning the lower divisions and winning  promotion to the SPL for Gretna whose job is actually safe?

To surmise,  going forward, what if Brew starts to stagnate bigtime and the team continues to roll in the lower quagmire do you think  that his backers in the top tent would waste a lot of time keeping him on or would they approach John Robertson in the Green-Land with a view to Robbo coming back in the "all is forgiven" mode ?

And would anyone think that Robbo would seriously consider it? Personally speaking I think he would jump at it.......... :023:

Shall I get Agent Orange to start making inquiries ?  :cool02:

[Scarlet Pimple]

Or should Management go for Jimmy Calderwood?

I must say I like Jimmy for his always perky comments and I don't think he would be too worried about Brew's downfall do yew's?

This guy is quite a character and often very amusing. Got soirit that's for sure. he  you listen to Craig you find he is a different character all together, and as Eric Idle used to say..."say no more, say no more". :001:

[tm4tj]

erm Scarlet, I think Jimmy Calderwood may well be top of most peoples hate list over here, he is a grossly disliked manager and public enemy number one :32: :32:

[L_G]

Why are we even considering a replacement for Brew. I don't think he's going anywhere in the near future.

[RiG]

I don't think that is the prupose of the thread.

[L_G]

I agree RIG but it seems to be heading down that road.

Okay to get back on topic - IHE - I don't know what, what is the difference?  :003:

[RiG]

I agree RIG but it seems to be heading down that road.

USE YOUR MODERATOR SUPERPOWERS TO STOP THIS HAPPENING AND SAVE THE WORLD!!!

:001:

[L_G]

:rotflmao: :rotflmao:

[IMMORTAL HOWDEN ENDER]

DOH - Here is a clue. One admitted on a few occasions that he had made an error of judgement and I can recall him apologising on at least a couple of occasions - one blamed everything and everything else other than himself - and the other tends to go down the silence or no comment route.

[Scarlet Pimple]

TMFTJ--I know, I know, but one must  say something controversial just to keep the thread interesting.... :016:

And you have to admit he is a more animated speaker on the radio than another Manager we know . Spirited guy..eh? :symbol_question:

[tm4tj]

He is also orange, but that disnae make him right.